Over ice vs over water
Above freezing there is only one saturation curve. Below 0 °C there are two: one for equilibrium with supercooled liquid water and a lower one for equilibrium with ice. The gap is small near 0 °C and widens as it gets colder, peaking around −12 °C. That difference is not academic — it is the engine behind frost formation and behind the growth of ice crystals in mixed-phase clouds, and it is why the frost point is reported separately from the dew point.
This calculator evaluates the ice-specific equations directly. For saturation over liquid water, or a head-to-head of every formula at one temperature, use the main calculator; to see the whole picture at once, the phase diagram shows the sublimation curve meeting the vaporization curve at the triple point.
Where it matters
Vapor pressure over ice underpins frost and freeze forecasting, the design of freeze-drying (lyophilization) cycles in food and pharmaceutical processing, humidity control in cold storage, and atmospheric work on cirrus clouds and polar stratospheric clouds. In all of these, the relevant equilibrium is with ice, not liquid water, so using an over-water formula below freezing introduces a real and avoidable error.
Frequently asked questions
What is the saturation vapor pressure over ice?
It is the pressure of water vapor in equilibrium with a flat ice surface at a given temperature — the point where sublimation and deposition balance. Below 0 °C it is lower than the saturation pressure over supercooled liquid water at the same temperature, and the temperature at which air becomes saturated with respect to ice is called the frost point (the ice equivalent of the dew point).
Why does vapor pressure over ice differ from over water below freezing?
Below 0 °C, water vapor can be in equilibrium with either ice or supercooled liquid water, and the two equilibrium pressures are not equal — the pressure over ice is lower. That difference is what drives the Wegener–Bergeron–Findeisen process in clouds, where ice crystals grow at the expense of supercooled droplets, and it is why frost (deposition onto ice) forms under conditions where dew would not.
Which formula is most accurate over ice?
Murphy & Koop (2005) is the modern reference for vapor pressure over ice, valid down to about 110 K, and this calculator uses it as the baseline. Buck (1996), the Alduchov–Eskridge Magnus form, and Goff–Gratch each have ice-specific coefficient sets that agree with Murphy–Koop to a fraction of a percent across normal conditions; the comparison table shows exactly how far each deviates at your temperature.
What is the difference between frost point and dew point?
Both are the temperature to which air must cool to reach saturation, but the frost point is defined with respect to ice and the dew point with respect to liquid water. When the air is below 0 °C, the frost point is slightly higher than the dew point for the same moisture content. Meteorological relative humidity is conventionally reported over liquid water even below freezing (the WMO convention), so the two are reported separately.
References
Every formula on this page is implemented from, and validated against, the following primary standards and papers — see the verification methodology.
- Review of the vapour pressures of ice and supercooled water — Murphy & Koop 2005, QJRMS 131:1539
- Humidity Conversion Equations (rev. 7/96) — Buck Research CR-1A manual — the Buck 1996 coefficients
- Improved Magnus Form Approximation of Saturation Vapor Pressure — Alduchov & Eskridge 1996, J. Appl. Meteorol. 35:601
- Goff–Gratch equation (Smithsonian Met. Tables 1984) — Vömel (CIRES) tabulation — corrected form
Spotted an error? Let us know — reader corrections are the best review this site gets.